Bankruptcy: Bank's Security Interest - Stocks pledged as Security

     In the case of Winters v. George Mason Bank the United States District Court, reviewing a case from the United States Bankruptcy Court at Alexandria, Virginia, affirmed a ruling for the creditor bank which enforced the bank's security interest against stocks held jointly by a mother and daughter and pledged as collateral for the bank's loan (actually a series of loans) to the daughter and her husband (which were in default), even though the daughter and her husband had declared bankruptcy. 

     The District Court found that from over the course of three years the plaintiff signed a total of three commercial pledge agreements pledging as collateral her interest in the stocks. In the second of three years the daughter and her husband filed a bankruptcy petition. The plaintiff argued that because she and her daughter jointly owned the stocks, those stocks were part of the bankruptcy estate. The plaintiff also argued that the second pledge agreement was an act to create or perfect a lien against that property, and thus violated the automatic stay provision of the Bankruptcy Code. The District Court ruled, however, that the automatic stay did not apply to non-bankrupt codebtors, nor did the automatic stay prevent actions against guarantors of loans. The District Court further stated that even if the agreement violated the stay as to the debtors, the agreement did not violate the stay as to the plaintiff. The District Court found that the plaintiff's attempt to use the automatic stay to her own benefit contradicted the purpose behind the stay provision. The plaintiff sought to use the automatic stay to avoid an agreement that was beneficial to the bankruptcy estate, and an agreement that she and the debtors had voluntarily entered into. Accordingly, the District Court upheld the bank's lien.