Showing posts with label Proof of Claim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Proof of Claim. Show all posts

Monday, February 1, 2021

Creditors, Let’s Talk about Bankruptcy!

     Bankruptcy! This is not a topic that most creditors wish to discuss! However, with Judges still “reacting” to the economic downturn of the last few years, with bankruptcy filings on the rise, with the conversion of many Chapter 13 cases to Chapter 7, with the aggressive lawsuits filed by counsel for debtors for violations of consumer laws, with increasingly detrimental provisions in Chapter 13 plans, and, with the strict review of proofs of claim and the requirements for the same, we should talk! 
     In regard to proofs of claim, our local bankruptcy courts require that if you are alleging a security interest in the debtor’s principal residence, in addition to the proof of claim form, you must also file a completed form B 10 (Attachment A) setting out the principal due, interest due, late fees, returned check fees, attorney’s fees, escrow shortage, amount due to bring loan current, etc. In addition, each time the debtor becomes delinquent on their mortgage during the bankruptcy, you must file form B 10 (Supplement 2), setting out late charges and other expenses charged to the debt. In the event the debtor’s mortgage payment amount changes due to increase or decrease in interest rate, insurance premiums or real estate taxes, form B Supplement (1) will need to be filed. 
     Obviously, this is a more complex and detailed filing, and, certainly, will be closely scrutinized. While you can file your own proofs of claim, we can also do it for you. 
     Creditors must be very careful to fully redact ALL “identifying data” (this includes procedure codes and/or other identifying treatment references for healthcare providers) on court filings to help protect debtors’ vital information from identity theft. Failure to do so will result in a court award of sanctions and attorney’s fees. Several local bankruptcy attorneys are reviewing all proofs of claim in their cases to spot possible violations. I have already had clients who have filed their own proofs of claim and been sued for violations. This is a very expensive problem. 
     Accordingly, I am still offering a “flat rate” fee for filing your proofs of claim and ask that you consider taking advantage of the same. In the end, I think that this will be a less costly and better alternative for you. I will file your first proof of claim in a case for a charge of $250.00. Second and subsequent pleadings for the same case will be billed at one half hour, and one quarter hour respectively. 
     I invite you to please call me so that we can discuss your questions. 
Eddie

Monday, January 13, 2020

Creditors, Let’s Talk about Bankruptcy!

     Bankruptcy! This is not a topic that most creditors wish to discuss! However, with Judges still “reacting” to the economic downturn of the last few years, with bankruptcy filings on the rise, with the conversion of many Chapter 13 cases to Chapter 7, with the aggressive lawsuits filed by counsel for debtors for violations of consumer laws, with increasingly detrimental provisions in Chapter 13 plans, and, with the strict review of proofs of claim and the requirements for the same, we should talk! 
     In regard to proofs of claim, our local bankruptcy courts require that if you are alleging a security interest in the debtor’s principal residence, in addition to the proof of claim form, you must also file a completed form B 10 (Attachment A) setting out the principal due, interest due, late fees, returned check fees, attorney’s fees, escrow shortage, amount due to bring loan current, etc. In addition, each time the debtor becomes delinquent on their mortgage during the bankruptcy, you must file form B 10 (Supplement 2), setting out late charges and other expenses charged to the debt. In the event the debtor’s mortgage payment amount changes due to increase or decrease in interest rate, insurance premiums or real estate taxes, form B Supplement (1) will need to be filed.
     Obviously, this is a more complex and detailed filing, and, certainly, will be closely scrutinized. While you can file your own proofs of claim, we can also do it for you. 
     Creditors must be very careful to fully redact ALL “identifying data” (this includes procedure codes and/or other identifying treatment references for healthcare providers) on court filings to help protect debtors’ vital information from identity theft. Failure to do so will result in a court award of sanctions and attorney’s fees. Several local bankruptcy attorneys are reviewing all proofs of claim in their cases to spot possible violations. I have already had clients who have filed their own proofs of claim and been sued for violations. This is a very expensive problem. 
     Accordingly, I am still offering a “flat rate” fee for filing your proofs of claim and ask that you consider taking advantage of the same. In the end, I think that this will be a less costly and better alternative for you. I will file your first proof of claim in a case for a charge of $250.00. Second and subsequent pleadings for the same case will be billed at one half hour, and one quarter hour respectively. 
     I invite you to please call me so that we can discuss your questions. 
Eddie

Monday, December 31, 2018

Creditors, let's talk about bankruptcy.

     Bankruptcy! This is not a topic that most creditors wish to discuss! However, with Judges still “reacting” to the economic downturn of the last few years, with bankruptcy filings on the rise, with the conversion of many Chapter 13 cases to Chapter 7, with the aggressive lawsuits filed by counsel for debtors for violations of consumer laws, with increasingly detrimental provisions in Chapter 13 plans, and, with the strict review of proofs of claim and the requirements for the same, we should talk! 
     In regard to proofs of claim, our local bankruptcy courts require that if you are alleging a security interest in the debtor’s principal residence, in addition to the proof of claim form, you must also file a completed form B 10 (Attachment A) setting out the principal due, interest due, late fees, returned check fees, attorney’s fees, escrow shortage, amount due to bring loan current, etc. In addition, each time the debtor becomes delinquent on their mortgage during the bankruptcy, you must file form B 10 (Supplement 2), setting out late charges and other expenses charged to the debt. In the event the debtor’s mortgage payment amount changes due to increase or decrease in interest rate, insurance premiums or real estate taxes, form B Supplement (1) will need to be filed. 
     Obviously, this is a more complex and detailed filing, and, certainly, will be closely scrutinized. While you can file your own proofs of claim, we can also do it for you. 
     Creditors must be very careful to fully redact ALL “identifying data” (this includes procedure codes and/or other identifying treatment references for healthcare providers) on court filings to help protect debtors’ vital information from identity theft. Failure to do so will result in a court award of sanctions and attorney’s fees. Several local bankruptcy attorneys are reviewing all proofs of claim in their cases to spot possible violations. I have already had clients who have filed their own proofs of claim and been sued for violations. This is a very expensive problem. 
     Accordingly, I am still offering a “flat rate” fee for filing your proofs of claim and ask that you consider taking advantage of the same. In the end, I think that this will be a less costly and better alternative for you. I will file your first proof of claim in a case for a charge of $250.00. Second and subsequent pleadings for the same case will be billed at one half hour, and one quarter hour respectively. 
     I invite you to please call me so that we can discuss your questions. 
Eddie

Monday, August 6, 2012

Bankruptcy: Amended Proof of Claim for Added Interest and Fees Disallowed in a Chapter 13 Case

     In the case of In re: Michael K. Hedrick, the United States Bankruptcy Court at Alexandria held that in a Chapter 13 case, converted from a Chapter 7 case, a credit union may not amend its proof of claim for a debt from an auto loan.
     Prior to filing for bankruptcy, the debtors defaulted on their auto loan.  The vehicle was repossessed and sold.  There was a deficiency balance due after the sale.  The credit union filed a proof of claim for the joint deficiency claim of $5,693.00, as of the date the case was filed.  Three months after the confirmation of the debtor’s modified chapter 13 plan, the credit union filed an amended proof of claim, increasing its claim by $2,430.00, for post petition interest and attorney’s fees.
     The credit union argued that a Chapter 13 plan must pay unsecured creditors at least as much as under the Chapter 13 plan as they would receive if the case were under Chapter 7.  If this case had been under Chapter 7, joint unsecured creditors - but not individual unsecured creditors - would be paid in full together with interest because of the equity in the jointly owned house.  The credit union used the contract rate of interest.  It treated its post petition attorney’s fees the same as post petition interest.
     The Court noted that even though the proper allowed claim is the original claim filed by the credit union, the credit union may actually be paid more than its allowed claim if the estate is a solvent estate.  The Court “shall confirm” a Chapter 13 plan if all of the requirements of Bankruptcy Code Section 1325(a) are satisfied.  One requirement is that the distribution to unsecured creditors must be at least as much as they would have received had the case been a Chapter 7 case.  The provision for interest on allowed claims in solvent estates is a part of this calculation.
     The Court ruled, though, that the interest rate is the federal judgment rate, not the contract rate or the applicable state rate.  There is no similar statutory provision for attorney’s fees or for other reasonable fees, costs or charges provided for under the agreement which the claim arose.
     The Court ruled that the credit union’s first proof of claim is the proper proof of claim.  The allowed claim of an unsecured creditor in a solvent estate is the same as in an insolvent estate.  It is determined as of the date of the filing of the petition and does not include post petition interest, attorney’s fees costs or other contractual charges.
     The Court ruled that if the terms of a confirmed Chapter 13 plan include post petition interest, the Chapter 13 trustee will pay that interest as provided in the plan.  If the plan does not provide for post petition interest, the trustee may not pay post petition interest.  In this case, the confirmed plan contains no such provision.
     The Court concluded that the proper construction of the Chapter 13 plan was that the allowed joint unsecured claims would be paid 100 percent of the amount allowed joint unsecured claim without interest.  Had the matter been brought to the Court’s attention at the confirmation hearing, the plan would not have been confirmed without a provision for payment of post petition interest on allowed joint unsecured claims.  It was not and the plan was confirmed.
     The lesson of Hedrick: read Chapter 13 plans very carefully and object timely.